Skip header and navigation
CMA PolicyBase

Policies that advocate for the medical profession and Canadians


2 records – page 1 of 1.

A Doctor for Every Canadian - Better Planning for Canada's Health Human Resources: The Canadian Medical Association's brief to the House of Commons Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities - Addressing Existing Labour Shortages in High-Demand Occupations

https://policybase.cma.ca/en/permalink/policy10387
Date
2012-05-09
Topics
Health human resources
  1 document  
Policy Type
Parliamentary submission
Date
2012-05-09
Topics
Health human resources
Text
The Canadian Medical Association (CMA) is pleased to present this brief for consideration by the House of Commons Standing Committee on Human Resources, Skills and Social Development and the Status of Persons with Disabilities as part of its current study, Fixing the Skills Gap: Addressing Existing Labour Shortages in High Demand Occupations. The health sector provides essential services and high value jobs supporting communities across Canada. Statistics Canada reports that employment in the health sector accounts for 10 per cent of the Canadian labour force.i Beyond the renewed commitment for the long-term fiscal arrangement for health care, Canada requires a pan-Canadian approach to health human resources planning to achieve self-sufficiency in health human resources. This submission focuses on physicians and proposes action at the federal level to begin to address specific shortages and ensure a needs-based specialty mix distribution and self-sufficiency for our country. Health Care Transformation In 2010, the CMA initiated a cross-country consultation with Canadians on the future of the health care system. Based on that input, the CMA, together with the Canadian Nurses Association, developed six principles to guide health care transformation. These principles have since been endorsed by over 100 medical, health and patient organizations. One of the principles is sustainability. Sustainable health care requires universal access to quality health services that are adequately resourced and delivered along the full continuum in a timely and cost-effective manner. Addressing health human resource shortages is critical to ensuring a sustainable, accessible and patient-centred health care system. The principles outline a vision to ensure adequate health human resources: health care will be delivered within collaborative practice models; pan-Canadian eligibility for licensure will support inter-provincial portability of all health care providers; and health human resource planning will align with communities in the short, medium and long term. In fulfillment of this vision, this submission will focus on: * Ensuring a needs-based specialty mix; * Targeting health infrastructure investment to optimize the supply of health human resources; and * Foreign credential recognition. Physician Shortages Canada's experience with physician shortages dates back to the mid-1990s following significant cuts to first-year medical school enrolment. While there have been substantial increases since then, it took a decade to rebound. In 2010, first-year enrolment stood at 2,830 - 80 per cent higher than the mid-1990s.ii Despite these significant gains, Canada's supply of physicians relative to our population is well below the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) average.iii Indeed, with the seventh-lowest supply of physicians per capita among OECD nations, Canada ranks below the European Union nations and the United States. Currently, between four million and five million Canadians do not have a family physician. Over one-third of all Canadian physicians are over the age of 55. Many will either retire soon or reduce their practice workload. Many physician practices are at capacity and unable to take on new patients. Findings from the CMA's 2012 survey of provincial-territorial medical associations (PTMAs) with respect to physician resources underscore the pressing need for a pan-Canadian approach to health human resources planning.iv While all jurisdictions in Canada are experiencing challenges, shortages by type of practice vary by jurisdiction. Issue 1: Needs-based Specialty Mix A sustainable health care system requires health human resource planning to ensure an appropriate specialty mix. At present, there is no pan-Canadian system to monitor or manage the specialty mix. The findings from the 2012 CMA survey of PTMAs revealed that only three jurisdictions have a long-term physician resource plan in place, while only one jurisdiction employs a supply and needs-based projection model. To illustrate the consequences of the lack of monitoring and management of the physician specialty mix, from 1988 to 2010, the numbers of post-graduate trainee positions in geriatric medicine were essentially constant at only 18 positions, while the number of trainees in pediatric medicine increased by 58 per cent.v It has been almost four decades since the federal government has completed a needs-based projection of physician requirements in Canada. The last federally commissioned study, the Report of the Requirements Committee on Physician Manpower to the National Committee on Physician Manpower, was published by the Minister of National Health and Welfare in 1975. Recommendation 1 The CMA recommends that the federal government, in collaboration with medical organizations, lead a benchmark study on the current specialty mix in Canada, as well as a supply and needs-based projection to support health human resources planning. Issue 2: Targeted Health Infrastructure Adequate health infrastructure is an important element in optimizing the capacity of health human resources. Health infrastructure shortages have been reported as a limiting factor on physician resources. For example, the recruitment of specialists and sub-specialists is being affected not by a lack of demand for their services, but, rather, by the limitations of existing hospital infrastructure, such as operating rooms. This too has been revealed by the CMA's 2012 survey of PTMAs. Ensuring there is sufficient health infrastructure to optimize the current capacity of health human resources would no doubt help address Canada's persistent problems with wait times. Recommendation 2 The CMA recommends that a targeted health infrastructure fund be established to address infrastructure shortages that prevent the optimization of health human resources and exacerbate wait times. Issue 3: Foreign Credential Recognition The CMA recognizes the federal government's commitment to address foreign credential recognition and that physicians are among the target group for 2012. The medical profession is well positioned to support the federal government's objective. Under the auspices of the National Assessment Collaboration, a group of federal, provincial and other stakeholders, the medical profession is currently working to streamline the evaluation process for international medical graduates (IMGs) licensure in Canada. Related to this effort, the pan-Canadian portable eligibility for licensure is an important issue in health human resources, especially for physicians. The CMA and the medical professional have been active in this important issue for many years. In 1992, the Federation of Medical Licensing Authorities of Canadavi adopted a national standard for portable eligibility for licensure. In 2009, the Federation of Medical Regulatory Authorities adopted an agreement on national standards for medical registration in Canada that reflects the revised labour mobility chapter of the Agreement on Internal Trade. FMRAC and the Medical Council of Canada are working on a one-stop process for IMGs to apply for licensure in Canada (with support from Human Resources and Skills Development Canada). The CMA fully supports bringing into practice qualified IMGs already in Canada. Canada has historically benefited from a steady flow of IMGs to our country. In fact, close to one-quarter of all physicians in Canada are IMGs. While IMGs may be seen as a key strategy to addressing shortages in Canada, actively recruiting from developing countries is not an acceptable solution to our physician shortage. Canada must strive for greater self-sufficiency in the education and training of physicians. In fact, self-sufficiency is a key principle of the Federal/Provincial/Territorial Advisory Committee on Health Delivery and Human Resources' Framework for Collaborative Pan-Canadian Health Human Resources Planning.vii Recommendation 3 The CMA recommends that the federal government continue to support the efforts of medical organizations to promote the pan-Canadian portable eligibility of licensure. Recommendation 4 The CMA recommends that the federal government continue to support efforts of medical organizations to streamline the process of credential verification and assessment of eligibility of licensure for IMGs. Conclusion Despite progress in addressing the shortage of physicians in Canada, serious challenges in health human resources persist. At present, few jurisdictions engage in health human resources planning. Further, despite changing shifting demographics, it has been almost four decades since the federal government has completed a study of physician requirements. Canada requires a pan-Canadian approach to ensure adequate health human resources in support of a sustainable health care system. Summary of Recommendations Recommendation 1 CMA recommends that the federal government, in collaboration with medical organizations, lead a benchmark study on the current specialty mix in Canada, as well as a supply and needs-based projection to support health human resources planning. Recommendation 2 The CMA recommends that a targeted health infrastructure fund be established to address infrastructure shortages that prevent the optimization of health human resources and exacerbate wait times. Recommendation 3 The CMA recommends that the federal government continue to support the efforts of medical organizations to promote the pan-Canadian portable eligibility of licensure. Recommendation 4 The CMA recommends that the federal government continue to support efforts of medical organizations to streamline the process of credential verification and assessment of eligibility of licensure for IMGs. i 2006 Census data ii Association of Faculties of Medicine of Canada. 2010. First Time Enrolment in Canadian Faculties of Medicine by Faculty of Medicine, 1994/95-2010/11. iii OECD. OECD Health Data 2011. Available at: http://www.oecd.org/document/60/0,3746,en_2649_33929_2085200_1_1_1_1,00.html iv CMA. Results of PTMA Physician Resource Interviews. v vi Since renamed the Federation of Medical Regulatory Authorities of Canada. vii Federal/Provincial/Territorial Advisory Committee on Health Delivery and Human Resources. 2009. How Many Are Enough? Redefining Self-Sufficiency for the Health Workforce A Discussion Paper.
Documents
Less detail

Letter - CMA’s 2006 Pre-Budget Submission to the Minister of Finance

https://policybase.cma.ca/en/permalink/policy2031
Last Reviewed
2013-03-02
Date
2006-04-19
Topics
Health human resources
Health systems, system funding and performance
  1 document  
Policy Type
Parliamentary submission
Last Reviewed
2013-03-02
Date
2006-04-19
Topics
Health human resources
Health systems, system funding and performance
Text
On behalf of the Canadian Medical Association (CMA), I am pleased to present you with our pre-budget submission for your government's consideration. The CMA appreciates the opportunity to provide input into this government's first budget and to identify strategic investment opportunities for the long term health of Canadians. While Canada's health system faces many challenges, we believe that immediate action by the federal government in four key areas will offer both short term and long term benefits. They are: (1) the establishment of a Canada Health Access Strategy to support a patient wait-times guarantee; (2) a proposed Visa position buyback program and a repatriation program to immediately address shortfalls in health human resources; (3) a strengthening of Canada's public health infrastructure; and (4) a remedy for GST-induced distortions in the health care system.We believe these proposals fit well with the government's stated priorities. While information on each of these recommendations is attached for your information and consideration, I would like to provide you with an overview of each. 1. CANADA HEALTH ACCESS STRATEGY The CMA has been advocating for the implementation of maximum wait time thresholds or care guarantees for a number of years and is pleased that the government has included this as one of its top five priorities. As a first step, the CMA worked with six other specialty societies as part of the Wait Times Alliance (WTA) to develop a set of pan-Canadian wait-time benchmarks or performance goals released last August. We believe this work served as a catalyst for the provincial and territorial governments to move some way toward meeting their commitment in announcing pan-Canadian wait-time benchmarks last December. We must continue to work with governments and the academic community to improve access to medical care beyond the five priority health issues identified in the First Ministers' 2004 10-year health care plan. The second step in implementing patient wait-time guarantees is the issue of honouring the commitment and providing for patient recourse. As a member of the WTA, the CMA strongly supports accelerating the timetable to reduce wait times nationwide. However, the federal government needs to do its part to assist provinces in advancing the timetable by stepping up the flow of funds earmarked for the last four years of the accord. Our proposed Canada Health Access Strategy is comprised of three components directed at making this happen: supporting provinces to expand capacity and to handle surges in demand; supporting the creation of regional and/or national referral networks; and establishing a Canada Health Access Fund for a "safety valve" to help Canadians access care elsewhere when necessary. Details on how this Strategy would work are attached. The point is that this Strategy is necessary to assure Canadians that they get the care they need when they need it. Recommendation 1. The federal government advance the remaining $1 billion from the 2004 First Ministers Accord that was originally intended to augment the Wait Times Reduction Fund (2010-2014) to support a Canada Health Access Strategy by: (a) expanding provincial surge capacity : $500 million to be flowed immediately to provinces on a per capita basis in return for agreement to accelerate the timetable for bringing down wait times, as was promised in the recent federal election campaign; (b) improving national coordination of wait time management: $250 million to support creation of regional and/or national referral networks, a more coordinated approach to health human resource planning, expansion of information technology solutions to wait time management and facilitation of out-of-country referrals; and (c) establishing a Canada Health Access Fund: $250 million initial investment in an alternative patient recourse system or "safety valve" when and if clinically-indicated maximum wait time benchmarks as agreed to by provinces/territories last December are exceeded. Addressing Shortfalls in Health Human Resources As identified by Minister Clement in a recent speech at the "Taming of the Queue III" wait-time conference, addressing shortages in health human resources is a key element of any strategy for reducing lengthy wait-times. Unfortunately, we face serious physician shortages, starting with family physicians. The bad news is that it can take several years to educate and train the necessary professionals. The good news is that there are some strategies that can be undertaken to address the situation in the short term. 2. VISA POSITION BUYBACK FUND One such strategy is our Visa Position Buyback proposal that would eliminate the backlog of 1,200 qualified international medical graduates (IMGs) over the next five to seven years. Currently, these qualified IMGs, who are either Canadian citizens or landed immigrants, are unable to access the necessary residency training. One existing source for training capacity exists with the positions purchased by foreign governments for visa trainees. We estimate that there are over 900 current visa trainees at all rank levels. By implementing the Visa Position Buyback program, the government is able to take an immediate step that will produce tangible results as soon as a two to four years from now. This initiative would be part of a longer term plan to fully address the shortages in health human resources and help the government meet its commitment to implement a properly functioning patient wait-time guarantee. Recommendation 2a. The federal government allocate $381.6 million toward the training of up to 1,200 IMGs through to practice over the 2007/08 to 2015/16 period. Funding would be made available in two installments: an immediate investment of $240 million and the remaining $140 million subject to a satisfactory progress report at the end of five years. Repatriate Health Professionals Working in the United States Fortunately, another short-term source of health professionals exists that Canada should pursue. Thousands of health care professionals are currently working in the United States including approximately 9,000 Canadian trained physicians. We know that many of the physicians who do come back to Canada are of relatively young age meaning that they have significant practice life left. While a minority of these physicians do come back on their own, many more can be repatriated in the short-term through a relatively small but focussed effort by the federal government led by a secretariat within Health Canada. Recommendation 2b. The federal government should establish a secretariat within Health Canada that would provide funding to national professional associations to conduct targeted campaigns to encourage the repatriation of Canadian health professionals working in the United States, and act as a clearinghouse on issues associated with returning to Canada (e.g., citizenship, taxation, etc.). 3. PUBLIC HEALTH INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL The CMA remains concerned about the state of Canada's public health system. Public health, including the professionals providing public health services, constitutes our front line against a wide range of threats to the health of Canadians. While there is much talk about the arrival of possible pandemics, Canada's public health system must be ready to take on a broad range of public health issues. The CMA has been supportive of the Naylor report which provides a blue print for action and reinvestment in the public health system for the 21st century. While this will take several years to achieve, there are some immediate steps that can be taken which will lessen the burden of disease on Canadians and our health care system. These steps include establishing a Public Health Partnership Program with provincial and territorial governments to build capacity at the local level and to advance pandemic planning. In addition, we call on the government to continue its funding of immunization programs under its National Immunization Strategy. Recommendation 3a. The federal government should establish a Public Health Infrastructure Renewal Fund in the amount of $350 million annually to establish a Public Health Partnership Program with the provincial/territorial governments for the purposes of building capacity at the local level and advancing pandemic planning. In addition, the $100 million per year for immunization programs under the National Immunization Strategy should be continued. 4. A REMEDY FOR GST-RELATED DISTORTIONS IN THE HEALTH SYSTEM The CMA and many other national health organizations are concerned about the increasing, unintended and negative consequences the GST is having on health care. For example, the 83% rebate originally provided for under the so-called "MUSH" formula is no longer tax neutral and is acting as a deterrent in some cases toward increased use of ambulatory care services such as day surgeries. Over the past 15 years the physicians of Canada have faced a large and growing unfair tax burden due to the GST. Since physicians' services are tax exempt under the law, physicians are unable to either claim input tax credits or pass on the tax because of the prohibition under the Canada Health Act of billing patients directly. This puts physicians in a unique and patently unfair catch 22 that now amounts to over $65 million per year, which further acts as a deterrent to repatriating or retaining Canadian physicians. Recommendation: 4a. That the federal government, in the course of reducing the GST from 7% to 5% further to its campaign commitments, remove the large and growing deterrent effects of the GST on the efficient and effective delivery of health care in Canada. In summary, the CMA is providing you with recommendations on strategic investments to help your government honour its commitment to timely access to care and to improve the health of Canadians. Our recommendations are financially reasonable, making good use of Canadians' tax dollars. We look forward to meeting with you on April 19 to discuss our proposals with you. Sincerely, Ruth L. Collins-Nakai, MD, MBA, FRCPC, MACC President c.c. The Honourable Tony Clement, Health Minister
Documents
Less detail